Every cheesecake starts the same way, Stetson’s New York recipe, made fresh in his KC kitchen, one at a time. New here? Start with The Original and work your way down.
The flagship
The Original
“Stetson's NY recipe, nothing on top”
The one that started it all. Stetson’s New York recipe, made exactly the way it was meant to be, dense, creamy, and bare, so there is nowhere for a mistake to hide. Every other flavor on this menu grew out of this one.
SignatureOn request
Vegan & gluten free
Stetson makes both. They take longer and the price depends on what you want, so they are not on the list above. Ask him and he will tell you what is possible.
Ask about one →Allergies
He’d rather know first
Have an allergy? Tell Stetson in the notes when you order, or talk to him first, and he’ll look after you.
The Classics
the ones you can't go wrong with
For the Chocolate Heads
if one chocolate isn't enough
Fruit & Tropical
a little vacation in cheesecake form
Cake-Shop Crossovers
your favorite cake, but better
Seasonal & Limited
here when they're here, gone when they're not